A provider's BNG is where subscribers first meet the network. The two most common models worldwide are PPPoE and IPoE. Both do the same job: identify the subscriber, assign an address and apply speed and policy. They differ in how they authenticate and how they are run.
PPPoE
PPPoE builds a PPP session over Ethernet. The subscriber's CPE logs in with a username and password, the BNG checks them against RADIUS and assigns an address and speed from the returned profile.
Strengths
- Clear, familiar authentication: username, password and RADIUS.
- A well-defined session, so start, stop and duration are easy to track.
- Most existing billing systems were built around PPPoE.
Watch out for
- The PPPoE header adds 8 bytes, dropping MTU to 1492. Without MSS clamping some sites misbehave.
- The BNG keeps state for every session, so its session capacity has to be sized properly.
IPoE
With IPoE the subscriber gets an address over DHCP. Identity comes from the VLAN they connect on (for example one VLAN per subscriber with QinQ) or from DHCP option 82; no username or password is needed.
Strengths
- Full 1500-byte MTU with no extra header.
- Simple CPE setup; plug it in and it works.
- IPv6 follows naturally with DHCPv6.
Watch out for
- Identity relies on the physical connection, so the access network's VLAN or option 82 plan must be clean.
- Sessions end on DHCP lease expiry or idle timeout, so monitoring works differently from PPPoE.
Which should you choose?
| Criterion | PPPoE | IPoE |
|---|---|---|
| Authentication | Username and password | VLAN or option 82 |
| MTU | 1492 | 1500 |
| CPE setup | Needs credentials | Plug and play |
| Fit with existing billing | Very high | May need adapting |
| IPv6 | DHCPv6-PD over PPPoE | Native DHCPv6 |
For wireless ISPs and networks that grew up on PPPoE, PPPoE is the easy path. New fibre builds with a clean VLAN plan can simplify operations with IPoE. In practice many providers run both: existing subscribers stay on PPPoE while new areas launch on IPoE.
With CoreGate BNG
CoreGate BNG runs PPPoE and IPoE side by side on the same platform, on different VLANs. Both connect to the same RADIUS and billing, and CoA applies speed changes without dropping sessions. Licensing follows concurrent PPPoE subscribers in five tiers from BNG-8K to BNG-128K.